A Hot Toddy is whiskey, honey, lemon, and hot water, and it takes about as long to make as a cup of tea. Because hot water opens a spirit up, the bottle you pick changes the drink more than in almost any other cocktail: a sherried Irish whiskey makes one toddy, a 101-proof bourbon makes a completely different one. Here's the recipe, what to look for, and 12 bottles in stock at Chips Liquor, sorted by the kind of toddy they make.
The Short Answer
- The classic: Jameson ($29.99)
- Best bourbon: Wild Turkey 101 ($24.99)
- Richest: Bushmills Black Bush ($29.99)
- Smoky: Johnnie Walker Double Black ($49.99)
- Not whiskey: El Dorado 12 Year Rum ($48.95)
The Hot Toddy Recipe
- 2 oz whiskey
- 1 tablespoon honey
- ½ oz fresh lemon juice
- 4 to 6 oz hot water
- Lemon wheel and a cinnamon stick; cloves if you have them
Fill a mug with hot water for a minute to warm it, then dump it. Add the honey and lemon, pour in fresh hot water, and stir until the honey dissolves. Add the whiskey last, then the lemon wheel and cinnamon stick.
Two details matter. Use water that's hot but not at a rolling boil, since boiling water drives off aroma and makes the alcohol smell harsh. And add the whiskey last, for the same reason. Taste before you adjust: more honey if it's sharp, more lemon if it's flat.
What Makes a Good Toddy Whiskey
Flavor that survives dilution. You're adding two to three parts water, so light, delicate whiskeys disappear. Bottles with some sherry cask, extra char, or higher proof keep their shape.
Not too much oak or peat, unless that's the point. Heat amplifies everything, including tannin and smoke. A heavily peated single malt in hot water is a lot. A lightly smoky blend is wonderful.
Don't overspend. Honey and lemon are doing a third of the work. Everything worth using is under $60.
Irish Whiskey: The Classic Toddy
Jameson ($29.99)
The default, and for good reason. Triple-distilled pot still and grain whiskey, aged at least four years, 80 proof: honey, vanilla, orchard fruit, toasted wood, and a little pot still spice. Its honeyed profile disappears into the drink in the best way. Smooth, easy, hard to get wrong.
Bushmills Black Bush ($29.99)
A high proportion of triple-distilled malt aged in ex-Oloroso sherry casks, blended with sweet grain whiskey, 80 proof. Dried fruit, nuts, dark chocolate, and spice. Same price as Jameson with a richer, fruitcake-leaning toddy to show for it. Add the cloves here.
Teeling Small Batch ($34.99)
Finished up to twelve months in Central American rum casks and bottled non-chill filtered at 46%, which is the reason to pick it: the extra proof holds up under hot water. Vanilla, tropical fruit, caramel, banana, honey, and baking spice. The Irish toddy with the most body.
Tullamore D.E.W. XO Caribbean Rum Cask ($35.99)
The triple-blend Tullamore finished in Caribbean rum casks, 43%. Banana, brown sugar, a hint of molasses, and honeyed spice. The sweetest toddy on the list; cut the honey to two teaspoons.
Bourbon and Rye: The American Toddy
Wild Turkey 101 ($24.99)
At 101 proof it still tastes like bourbon after six ounces of water. Caramel, vanilla, orange zest, cinnamon, and black pepper from heavy char barrels. Orange zest and cinnamon are already in the whiskey, which is why it works so well. The best value on this page.
Elijah Craig Small Batch ($29.99)
Eight-to-twelve-year barrels at 94 proof: vanilla, caramel, toasted nuts, brown sugar, dark cherry, and cinnamon. More oak than the others, so it makes a deeper, rounder toddy. Good with a dash of black walnut bitters.
Larceny Small Batch ($21.99)
A wheated bourbon at 92 proof, so it's soft where rye bourbons are sharp: caramel, honey, fresh bread, butterscotch, baked apple. The gentlest American toddy, and the cheapest bottle here.
Rittenhouse Rye Bottled in Bond ($27.99)
100 proof and 51% rye: dried banana, peach, malt, white pepper, and charred oak. Rye's spice plays the role the cloves usually do. For people who find a bourbon toddy too sweet.
Scotch: The Original
The toddy is generally traced to Scotland, where hot whisky with sugar and water was a standard cold-weather drink long before anyone added bourbon.
The Glenlivet 12 Year Double Oak ($42.99)
The benchmark Speyside single malt, 80 proof: ripe pear, pineapple, citrus, honey, marzipan, and soft oak. No smoke, lots of fruit and honey, which is exactly what the drink wants. A clean, elegant toddy.
Johnnie Walker Double Black ($49.99)
Black Label with the Islay and West Coast malts turned up, matured in heavily charred casks, 80 proof. Peat, dark fruit, toffee, raisin, black pepper, and campfire. Enough smoke to taste like a fireplace without the medicinal punch of a full Islay malt. The smoky toddy, done right.
Not Whiskey
El Dorado 12 Year Rum ($48.95)
Demerara rum from Guyana's heritage wooden stills, aged at least twelve years, 40%. Rum Ratings' drinkers describe chocolate, hazelnut, toffee, and rock candy. A rum toddy is richer and rounder than a whiskey one; use a little less honey and add an orange peel instead of lemon wheel.
Rémy Martin VSOP ($58.99)
Fine Champagne Cognac, 40%: ripe apricot, baked apple, vanilla, stone fruit, and gentle oak. Brandy was a common toddy base in the 1800s, and it makes the most refined version here. For a budget version, Martell VS Single Distillery ($35.99) does the job.
Four Easy Variations
- Tea toddy: swap the hot water for black tea or chamomile.
- Apple cider toddy: use hot cider instead of water and skip half the honey. Best with bourbon.
- Maple toddy: maple syrup instead of honey. Best with rye.
- Ginger toddy: steep a few slices of fresh ginger in the water for two minutes first.
Common Questions
What's the best whiskey for a Hot Toddy? Jameson for the classic, Wild Turkey 101 for bourbon, Black Bush for the richest.
Does a Hot Toddy help a cold? It's a warm drink with honey and lemon, which feels good on a sore throat. It isn't medicine, and alcohol doesn't treat a cold.
Can I make a batch? Yes. Keep honey, lemon, and hot water warm in a slow cooker on low, and add the whiskey to each mug as you serve so it doesn't cook off.
Shipping From Chips Liquor
Every bottle above is in stock at our Pacific Beach shop in San Diego and ships fast to most states. More winter drinks: the best whiskey for an Old Fashioned, the best rum for Hot Buttered Rum, and the best rum for eggnog. For more Irish bottles, see our Irish whiskey guide.
